Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gene Nelson, Ph.D.'s avatar

Thank you for this information debunking this Leftist narrative. Solar, wind, and batteries are parasite power, as a grid always requires generation providing reactive power and synchronous grid inertia. These requirements are set by the laws of physics and engineering. Those two critical attributes are provided by conventional thermal generation and large hydroelectricity.

To obscure this reality, at any time the California grid was supplying "100% solar and wind", the state was also exporting power to adjacent states - and paying those states to take that excess generation. Since solar, wind, and batteries always require conventional generation, this is one of the reasons why California's power rates are typically the highest in the continental U.S.

The political Left demanded that Spain demonstrate a modern industrial society could be powered mostly by sun and breezes. The result was the mid-day April 28, 2025 Iberian Peninsula blackout. At least eleven people who were depending on reliable electric power died. The economic damages stemming from lost productivity and damaged production equipment were measured in the equivalent of billions of U.S. dollars. Those harms have been under-reported since they don't align with the Left's goals. Consider also that the supply chains for all three technologies begin in the People's Republic of China. Thus, there is a mercantilist motivation for this set of policy choices.

Stu Turley's avatar

Ed, Outstanding article, and I am interviewing Ronald Stein on Monday - it would be fun to have you on a podcast when we can fit you in. I have also had Gene Nelson on, and he was FANTASTIC! With your permision, I would like to run this on the Energy News Beat website where we get about 2 million people a month - hope to get you some new subscribers

4 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?